10 Best Airtight Containers for Cookies (Reviews & Buying Guide)


Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no additional cost to you, if you make a purchase through the links. Read the disclaimer for more information.

While cookies are best eaten fresh right out of the oven, you can also store them for later. However, similar to any foods, there is a correct and wrong way of storing your cookies. Simply putting them in any container won’t do.

The right way to preserve your cookies is to store them in airtight storage containers. Apart from protecting your cookies from unwanted bugs and pests, an airtight container prevents air and moisture from affecting the original state of your cookies, so your cookies taste fresh much longer.

You can find a variety of airtight cookie jars and containers on the market, including plastic cookie containers with lids or dividers, glass cookie containers, and disposable cookie containers for giving away cookies.

Here are the top 10 best airtight containers for cookies available on the market today.

Summary of My Top 3 Picks

Best Overall

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B0051T92VS&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B0051T92VS

OXO SteeL POP Container

Best Runner-Up

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B075RS6H8X&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B075RS6H8X

Kook Glass Canister

Best Budget

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B006HCWRLK&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B006HCWRLK

OXO SteeL POP Container

Compare the best cookies storage containers

Product

Material

Lid Type

Design

Price

OXO Steel POP Container

BPA-free plastic

Push-up button

Rectangular

Kook Glass Canister

Glass

Glass lid with round knob

Round canister

OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar

BPA-free plastic

Push-up button

Angled-front with flat sides

OXO POP Round Canister

BPA-free plastic

Push-up button

Round canister

OGGI Clear Canister 

BPA-free plastic

Flip-top with clamp locks

Round canister

LOCK & LOCK Storage Container

BPA-free plastic

Four-sided locking lid

Rectangular

Sweetzer & Orange Glass Jar

Borosilicate Glass

Flat bamboo lid

Round canister

Bormioli Rocco PANDORA Glass Jar

Glass

Screw-on plastic lid

Angled-front with flat sides

Le’raze Set of 3 Glass Canister set

Glass

Glass lid with flat knob

Round canister

Outshine Vintage-Style Cookie Jar

Rust-resistant tin

Metal lid with handle

Round canister

Best airtight containers for cookies reviews

OXO Steel POP Container: Best Overall Pick

OXO steel POP containers are excellent for storing dry food like cookies. The container’s rectangular body with rounded or curved corners is made of sturdy BPA-free plastic. They also feature a stainless steel lid with a pop-up button mechanism. 

You can create an airtight environment for your cookies with an easy push of a button. The push-down button also makes it easy and quick for you to open the lids without having to ask for others’ assistance.

Once you press the button to open the lid, the button goes up and becomes a handle, allowing you to easily hold the lid and remove it from the container. 

They come in various sizes, ranging from ½ quarts up to 2.4 quarts, each container is designed to perfectly store common household staples, which include cookies, snacks, cereals, rice, pasta, sugar, and many more. 

Their elegant design makes your pantry look good and neat. Besides, you can stack them in a modular system. Since they have clear bodies, you can easily see the content of the container and know when you are running out of cookies.

Moreover, they are easy to cleanOpens in a new tab. and their silicone seal is dishwasher-safe.

Plus, the containers come with OXO Better Guarantee, which means that you can get in touch with the company in case you experience any problem with your container and ask for a repair or replacement.

Kook Glass Canister: Best Runner-up Pick

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B075RS6H8X&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B075RS6H8X

This airtight container is one of the best cookie storage containers on the market. It features a sturdy crystal clear round glass body with a glass lid. The lid has an airtight silicone seal to keep the cookies fresh. It also features a big knob in the middle for a firm hold.

Its design is simple yet sleek, perfect for the countertop cookie jar, and for storage in a pantry or open shelving.

It feels nice, looks nice, and is easy to open and close. It has a ½ gallon capacity. So you can use it to store almost anything from cookies to granola. 

OXO Good Grips POP Cookie Jar: Best Budget Pick

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B006HCWRLK&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B006HCWRLK

Whether you want to store cookies, trail mix, or pretzels, this affordable and cool cookie jar is an excellent choice to keep your snack fresh. Similar to OXO steel POP containers, these  BPA-free plastic cookie storage containers feature a push-up button mechanism.

With a simple press of the button, you can activate the silicone seal that keeps the containers airtight. When you’re ready to munch on your cookies, simply press the button again. The button will pop up and become a handle for you to easily remove the lid.

Their angled-front and flat back design let you store them in your shelves and pantries neatly while allowing you to reach and open them easily from the front. Plus, their circular opening allows easy access to cookies of a variety of sizes.

They come in large and medium-sized capacity. The medium-sized airtight cookie jar can fit up to 3 quarts of cookies while the large airtight cookie jar can hold up to 5 quarts of large cookies.

Moreover, these plastic cookie storage containers come with OXO Better Guarantee. So if you run into an issue with the containers, you can contact the company and ask for a replacement or repair.

OXO POP Round Canister

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B0073CC2SQ&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B0073CC2SQ

Similar to the OXO containers mentioned above, these plastic cookie containers with lids come with a push-button mechanism. You can make the containers airtight with just one push, and give another push on the button to open the container.

But unlike the OXO containers mentioned earlier, these containers have a cylindrical design. The BPA-free plastic is clear, so you can easily identify the contents and know when your cookies run out.

They come in various individual sizes, including small, large, and medium. You can also buy them in a set of three. The small round canisters can hold about 1.9 quarts of items, the medium ones can fit in 3 quarts worth of cookies and crackers, whereas the large ones have a capacity of 4.5 quarts, which are perfect for keeping cereals and a 5-pound bag of sugar or flour.

They also come with OXO Better Guarantee. So you can easily contact the company for repair or replacement if your containers are damaged or have other issues. 

OGGI Clear Canister with Locking Clamp

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00CSG0OP0&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B00CSG0OP0

This classic, see-through plastic cookies canister features a flip-top lid with chrome-plated clamp locks. Its lids have silicone gaskets to keep the container airtight and preserve your cookies freshness much longer.

This elegant-looking acrylic container can withstand break and shatter. It comes in various sizes, which include 28-ounce, 38-ounce, 59-ounce, 72-ounce, 150-ounce, and a tall 58-ounce pasta canister. The 72-ounce canister is especially great for storing your cookies, as well as other kitchen staples, including sugar, spices, and flour.

LOCK & LOCK Storage Container

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B0000AN4CK&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B0000AN4CK

This container is by far the most inexpensive one on the list. It looks pretty much the same as your common rectangular food storage containers and comes with a four-sided locking lid with silicone seal to keep your food completely airtight.

So you can store pretty much anything inside the containers, even your leftovers. Still, beware of any food with a strong odor that may be left on your containers. You don’t want your cookies to get the stinky smell afterward.

You can take them out directly from the freezer into the microwave safely. They come in various sizes, ranging from 1.5 cups to 8-cup containers.

Sweetzer & Orange Glass Jar with Bamboo lid

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07RBZR5TT&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B07RBZR5TT

These cylindrical glass cookie containers have a crystal clear body and come with a natural bamboo lid. Their elegant and sleek design makes them an ideal fit for a minimalist kitchen. 

They have a tight seal that ensures your cookies stay fresh for longer. As you open the container, you would hear the satisfying pop sound.

Aside from being BPA and lead-free, this airtight cookie jar is durable and made of 3 millimeters thick Borosilicate glass, which is thicker than other typical food jars. Their clear glass body displays your cookies nicely.

They come in various sizes and capacities, including small, medium, large, and extra-large, which can hold approximately 26.5 ounces, 39,75 ounce, 53 ounces, and 74.4 ounces, respectively. You can also get them in a set of 4, allowing you to store almost anything, including cookies, pasta, rice, lentils, candies, whole grains, and nuts.

Bormioli Rocco PANDORA Glass Jar

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07V49NKV9&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B07V49NKV9

These glass cookie containers come with a screw-on plastic lid that has a rubber gasket for an airtight closure. They have a unique design that allows you to display them in two ways: you can store them at a slant for easy access to your tasty cookies or let them stand on their bottom for a space-saving option.

They can hold up to about 2.4 quarts of cookies. Their wide opening makes it easy for you to reach your cookies. Plus, they are versatile. You can store all sorts of bakery goods, popcorn, candy, and snacks. 

You can also store dry foods like oats, nuts, and sugar. You can even use them to keep your non-food items like small toys, cotton balls, and sewing tools.

Le’raze Set of 3 Glass Canister set

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B017JA5TEA&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B017JA5TEA

This set of glass cookie containers are quite similar to Kook cookie jar with see-through glass bodies and airtight glass lids that come with a silicone ring. But instead of having a big knob on top of their lids, they have a flatter lid. 

These innovative cookie jars also come with a chalkboard front and chalk, so you can easily label your jar. Their stylish cylindrical silhouette makes them perfect for storing not just your favorite cookies, but also other dry food items, ingredients, as well as small accessories.

The set includes three different jar canister sizes, including 34-ounce, 43-ounce, and 54-ounce. You can line them up neatly on your counters without taking too much space.

Outshine Vintage-Style Cookie Jar

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07Y5PC3TH&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en USOpens in a new tab.ir?t=airtightcontainers05 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B07Y5PC3TH

If you have a farmhouse-themed decor, then this cute cookie jar with a classic feel would make an excellent addition to your kitchen.

This charming cookie container is made of high-quality tin and has a sturdy feel. It features an airtight lid and a firm metal handle that allows you to easily open and remove the lid. Also, it has a striking black “COOKIES” label on its white body which complements any space.

The best thing about this adorable cookie canister is that it can surprisingly hold up to 25 large monster cookies. Its unique design also makes it a perfect kitchen gift idea.

You can also get a mint-colored jar that can fit up to 20 monster cookies on Amazon hereOpens in a new tab.. This jar comes with 2 heart-shaped cookie cutters.

Alternative airtight storage containers for cookies

While these top ten best cookie storage containers are excellent options for keeping your cookies fresh, it doesn’t mean that they are the only options you’ve got.

There are plenty of other affordable and cheap options to store your favorite cookies. Here are some best alternatives to airtight food containers for storing cookies.

Alternative 1: Glass jars

Commercially used jars are usually airtight. This means that you can reuse any used jam jars, sauce jars, pickle jars, or condiment jars you have at home as an airtight container to store your cookies, that is if they are big enough. All you need to do is to wash them thoroughly to remove any remaining smell and dry them.

Alternative 2: Mason jars

Also called Ball or canning jars, Mason jarsOpens in a new tab. are getting popular over the years. Mason jars look pretty much the same as commercially used glass jars. 

The main difference between the two, however, is that Mason jars are designed with a wider rim for the better sealing surface. Also, their lids come in two pieces: a flat lid with a rubber ring and a reusable screw-threaded outer bail. (01Opens in a new tab.)

You can get these jars in various sizes, ranging from 4-ounce up to 128-ounce. They also come in a variety of colors.

Alternative 3: Airtight ziplock bags

Airtight Ziploc bags Opens in a new tab.are typically used for storing portions of food in the freezer and are an excellent option for keeping food on-the-go. But they also come in handy when it comes to storing a small batch of cookies. 

You can also use them to store cookies in decorative cookie jars which are not always airtight. All you need to do is to line the inside of your non-airtight pretty cookie jar with a Ziploc bag for airtight storage. (02Opens in a new tab.)

Airtight Container Buying Guides: How to choose the right airtight container for cookies?

Airtight food containers come in various sizes, styles, colors, and features. The overwhelming numbers of available airtight storage containers on the market make choosing the right container more difficult.

So at the very least, you should know the essential factors to consider when buying an airtight container. Below outlines some of these critical factors you need to pay attention to when it comes to buying an airtight container for cookies storage.

Types of lid

One major factor you need to consider when buying an airtight container is the types of the sealing system it has since it will be the ones responsible for blocking air. You can find various types of lids, the most common ones are the seal-cover and snap-ons lids. But you can also find containers with push-up buttons and hinge-locking mechanisms

You should choose ones that are easy for you to open and close without you having to ask other’s assistance or killing your hands.

Size

You can airtight containers of various capacities on the market, ranging from 2-cup to one-gallon capacity. Depending on how many cookies you often store, you would need a smaller or bigger container.

Material

Airtight food containers also come in many kinds of materials. The most common airtight storage containers are usually made of glass or BPA-free plastic.

Glass airtight containers are heavier than the plastic ones but do a better job at resisting stains and will not wrap. On the other hand, plastic airtight containers are light and less fragile. If you want to store your cookies in a plastic airtight container, make sure it is made of food-grade plastic.

Airtight food containers made of other types of materials, such as stainless steel, ceramic, silicone, acrylic, bamboo, wood, and aluminum are available as well.

Design and shape

The most common types of cookie containers are usually in the form of a cylinder or rectangular. Each shape has its benefits and disadvantages depending on your preference and the amount of space you have in your pantry or kitchen.

Rectangular or square containers are more suitable if you have a limited storage space. But round contrast enhances air circulation inside a container and allows faster cooling.

You may also find airtight food containers with unique designs like this cute ceramic retro-oven-inspired airtight cookie container.Opens in a new tab.

Durability

Another factor to consider is obviously, the container’s durability. A container that can last a few years saves you money and the hassle of buying a new container over and over again. The following are some useful questions you may want to ask yourself when evaluating the containers’ durability:

  • How long will the container last”
  • Is there a warranty offered by the manufacturer? How long is the warranty?
  • How long will the seal stay intact?
  • Can the container withstand extreme shocks or conditions?

Ease-of-cleaning

Naturally, you should pick an airtight cookie container that is easy to clean, especially the rubber gasket. Some airtight containers’ lids are dishwasher-safe, which makes cleaning much easier.

Additional functionality or features

Apart from the airtight feature, you may also want to consider other additional features that the container has to offer. These features may include stackability, dishwasher-safe, smell-proof, and stain-proof.

Other tips and tricks to keep your cookies fresh for longer

Storing your cookies inside an airtight container is only one of the many things you can do to extend your cookies’ lifespan. 

When it comes to cookie storage, there are two things you need to safeguard: the cookies’ quality and flavor. This means that your soft cookies should stay soft while your crispy cookies should stay hard, and not the other way around.

Also, if you’re planning to store different flavored cookies, you would have to make sure their taste and scent do not get mixed up. Here are more tips for storing your cookies the right way.

Make sure they are cool before storing them

Before putting your cookies inside a container, be sure to let it cooled completely. If you’re packaging them while they are still hot, they would become soggy because of the steam they’ve released. 

So you should leave your cookies on a cooling tray first before putting them inside a container. You can also leave your cookies on a plate instead of a cooling tray if you don’t have one. (03Opens in a new tab.)

Never mix different types of cookies together

You should never combine soft and crispy cookies inside the same container since the moisture from soft cookies will make your harder cookies slightly soften or become soggy. (04Opens in a new tab.)

Also, you should never mix cookies with a strong flavor to those with soft flavors in an airtight container.

Baking tip: If your hard cookies soften, you can restore them into their original crisp texture by heating them up in an oven at 300 degrees for around 10 minutes. You can also revive them by heating them in the oven within 4 to 5 minutes at 425 degrees.

When it comes to cookie bars storage, the best way to keep them fresh is by keeping them in the original baking pan that you use to bake them.  Then, cover them with a foil or put them in a resealable bag which is big enough to fit them. However, you should store your cookie bars in the refrigerator if they have perishable ingredients. (05Opens in a new tab.)

If you can’t store them in the original baking pan, you can cut them into squares and transfer them into an airtight container before storing them in the refrigerator. Your cookie bars will stay fresh for about seven to fourteen days.

Layer cookies with parchment or waxed paper

If you have a bulk batch of cookies and want to store them in layers, it’s best to use wax or parchment paper. These papers keep your cookies from sticking to each other or losing their crispness. If you don’t have parchment or wax paper, you can try using a tortilla instead.

Put one piece of white bread in the container to keep cookies fresh

To prevent your chewy cookies from becoming brittle and dry, you should store them in an airtight container with a tiny piece of white bread at room temperature. Avoid using more than half a slice of bread.

The bread releases moisture that allows your cookies to stay soft. If you don’t have any fresh white bread, you can drop in a tortilla or a piece of apple instead.

Store them at room temperature in a cool, dry place

Cookies are best stored in a cool, dry place away from the sun like your pantry’s back shelf. They typically last for a few days up to a few weeks at room temperature, depending on their variety. Soft homemade cookies usually stay fresh for about 3 days, whereas packaged or hard cookies typically last for about 2 weeks.

Store cookies in the freezer for longer lifespan

Most cookies stay fresh for a few days to a few weeks when you store them in airtight containers at room temperature. However, you can extend their shelf life further by storing them in the freezer inside an airtight container. Cookies can last for about 3 to 5 months in the freezer.

Before transferring your cookies into an airtight container or plastic bag, be sure to let them cooled completely to avoid condensation that turns the cookies soggy. Experts recommend choosing a sealable bag that is big enough to fit one single layer of cookies.

If you plan to add frosting your cookies, you should wait until the cookies have been thawed for an excellent icing taste and look.

Make sure to consume your cookies within five months for the best taste. You should write down the cookies date of entry and the estimated expiration date using a permanent marker.

When thawing the cookies, transfer them to a plate and leave them at room temperature for about 15 minutes. If you want to warm up your cookies, you can microwave them for about 10 seconds.

If you can’t finish the thawed cookies, you can keep them in an airtight container for up to seven days. If you still can’t finish the cookies within this time limit, it’s best to throw them out since the dairy products in your cookies would no longer be at their best.

Related Questions

What is the best way to store cookies?

Cookies are best stored in an airtight container. Storing them in the freezer can extend their shelf-life. Avoid stacking soft and crisp cookies together to avoid the latter from becoming soft. Also, never mix different flavored cookies in the same container.

What is the best container to store cookies?

The best container for cookie storage is an airtight container. An airtight container helps preserve the cookies’ softness by retaining moisture inside the container, thereby preventing the cookies from drying out and becoming brittle.

How do you keep homemade cookies fresh longer?

Homemade cookies stay fresh up to five months when stored inside an airtight container or resealable bag in the freezer. Be sure to transfer the cookies from the baking pan into the container after they are completely cooled to prevent condensation, which makes the cookies soggy.

Eina Aivoges

Eina Aivoges is a certified health and wellness coach and a licensed medical laboratory scientist. She's also a foodie, avid coffee drinker, cat-lover, blogger, and traveler.

Recent Content